which super smash bros is the best?

[Grand Poobah Marx]

I say the first all the way.  The second and third simply fucked the physics and ruined the fun feel.  They overcomplicated it.  I've played all three back to back to back and there is no doubt in my mind that the first is the best.

[IronSoldier820]

I voted for the first because it is the only one I have.

[Arsenal 10]

I voted first. It's the only one I've played..

[Ganon5]

I'll come back in 2 frickin months when I've had a chance to play brawl

[Flask]

The first. Although I do have the first and Melee, the first reigns supreme.

[pielord47]

The first was awesome but then you get to Melee and you go back to the first and you're like, "It's too slow. I have no up/down throws. I have no Front B."
And Melee is in no comparison to Brawl unless you've never played Brawl.

[KingRanter]

I cannot believe you people
Brawl is the greatest game to hit the shelves in any store worldwide
so what i say to you all is

PTHBTHPPPTHBBBTHHHTBTHHPTHH!!

EDIT: I make a alot of typos >_>

[pielord47]

I cannot believe you people
Brawl is the greatest game to his the shelves in any store worldwide
so what i say to you all is

PTHBTHPPPTHBBBTHHHTBTHHPTHH!!

this coming from the guy with Sonic as his avatar and Mario in his sig but yeah
I agree

[KingRanter]

only because sonic is cool and im good with him and i dont rly have a primary character cause im good with more than most of the brawl characters and the mario siggy pic i stole was the first siggy pic i found to steal and i didnt feel like looking anymore

but ive played all of them, and i like brawl best

EDIT: My avatar is Ike now that ive decided that this pic is absolutely epic

[Dontasemebro]

I recently played brawl. The items get VERY annoying. But the characters are awesome. I think SSBM was pretty balanced, but the first one will most likely stay my favorite. Brawl is still the best though for sheer # of characters and no one character being way better than everyone else.

[iron snake]

I like the second one best but I've never played Brawl because it's been delayed AGAIN anyone know what's going on there?

[MarioParty]

The only excuse for voting the first one is that you've never played the others. It's inferior in like every way!

[—-]

Voted first 'cause I threw my Mario game at my friend once... I was sad because I could never find it again, and in memory, I had to vote for it.

[invincible13matt]

Brawl, simply because the original was sluggish (at least, after playing Melee it is) and Melee was way too fast. Brawl simply has more content and a more comfortable playing speed. Plus, it has Ike and Smash Balls, even if Ike did get nerfed from his canon power level.

Furthermore, Donta, the items ('cept Smash Balls) should be turned off if you want a serious match, as I always have it (so easy to be cheaped with an item)

[Pterrydactyl]

No challenge.

PIT=WIN

[KingRanter]

The only excuse for voting the first one is that you've never played the others. It's inferior in like every way!

another reason people choose this is because its a classic. *rolls eyes*
..... but i mean rly, thats like choosing a revolver over some sort of hyper-death-cannon just cause the pistol is classic. i mean rly.

[KingRanter]

Voted first 'cause I threw my Mario game at my friend once... I was sad because I could never find it again, and in memory, I had to vote for it.

Super smash bros isnt a mario game, its a nintendo game. -.-

[pielord47]

Voted first 'cause I threw my Mario game at my friend once... I was sad because I could never find it again, and in memory, I had to vote for it.

Super smash bros isnt a mario game, its a nintendo game. -.-

although it does fall under the Mario franchise

[Prozach]

i just lost the game

[Untelligent]

Because Brawl is essentially Melee with moar levels, moar items, moar characters, and a stage editor (not an overly impressive stage editor, but still, IT'S A FREAKING STAGE EDITOR O:), I see no reason to vote for Melee unless you were a huge fan of Mewtwo, Dr. Mario, or Roy. So we're down to SSB and SSBB.

SSB was great, but the only thing it had over Melee was the Bumpers (seriously, did HAL actually think they could replace such an epic item with something as lame as the flipper?), a "board the platforms" bonus stage (cool, but not important), the level with the warp pipes (neat, but not much more important), giant-ass snorlaxen (did anyone else notice he seemed to have lost weight after the first game?), and nostalgia (I was going to say "oh, fuck, giant ass snorlax" here, but I decided to make that a seperate point altogether).

Brawl brought the Bumpers back, bringing SSB's selling points down to two unimportant points and one decent point, and Brawl has a shitload of other epicness, so Brawl wins my vote.